Next to the bar at Tongue N Cheek hangs a painting of a cow and a pig sharing a bottle of wine at a two-top. The cow is Roger and the pig is Whipple, and the room they hang in sits at the corner where Rogers and Whipple roads meet. For decades that room was Best Automotive's repair garage. Now it is a 45-seat restaurant and bar, and the butcher shop that spent twelve years in Wallingford Square is attached to it, according to the Portsmouth Herald's November 13 report.
The move changes where a Foreside evening can begin. A butcher counter and a dinner menu now share a building at one end of the neighborhood. Wallingford Square, which Maine Meat left behind, has picked up an oyster bar, a pizzeria and a wine bar over the past year. For a resident planning a weeknight dinner or a Saturday in December, the Foreside now has two ends worth walking between.
Twelve years from Wallingford Square to 2 Rogers Road
Shannon Hill and Jarrod Spangler brought Maine Meat to the Foreside in 2014. They wanted a restaurant beside the butcher shop from the start, but that plan stalled when a friend and likely business partner backed out, the Portsmouth Herald reported. Years earlier, Best Automotive co-owner Cissy Furbish had given the couple right of first refusal on her property.
The plan went to the Kittery Planning Board in early 2024. As Seacoastonline described it in March 2024, the existing garage measured 1,328 square feet, the finished building would total just over 3,400 square feet, and the old gas-station canopy would be torn down. The board approved it after a final review on April 11, 2024. The approved plan put the butcher shop in the original building and the restaurant and bar in a 2,076-square-foot addition, Seacoastonline reported that April. The couple signed a purchase-and-sale agreement in late July 2024. It was extended several times while the project worked through town review and Best Automotive wound down.
Among the letters supporting the project was one from Michael Landgarten, who founded Lil's Cafe and was the couple's landlord at 7 Wallingford Square. He wrote to the Planning Board about the corner itself:
"They have wisely and fortunately for us set their sights on a critical corner in the Foreside neighborhood. Standing at the intersection of multiple well-traveled streets their meat shop and new restaurant will, once complete, serve as a hub that connects now disparate parts of downtown."
The letter was quoted in Seacoastonline's coverage of the approval. That corner is now open. Maine Meat's own site says the shop moved to 2 Rogers Road in September 2026. Tongue N Cheek opened in late October, about a month later.
A dinner menu that starts at the butcher counter
Tongue N Cheek is co-owned by Hill, Spangler and Sam Demers, who runs back-of-house operations. Executive chef Ryan Hart runs the kitchen. The menu is seasonal and rotating, and it is built as an extension of the butcher shop. Hill describes it as the "baby" of The Black Birch, the Foreside favorite, and Turkey and the Wolf, a New Orleans sandwich shop and cocktail bar the couple loves.
Kittery Block Party regulars will know one item already: the Maine Meat all-beef corndog is on the opening menu. The appetizers include Spanish poutine, meatballs, wings, dumplings, beef tartare, an oxtail and beef cheek slider, and a lamb liver foie gras parfait. The sandwich section is called "On the Buns." Its signature is the Kittery Beef, which borrows from the Philadelphia cheesesteak, the Chicago Italian beef and the North Shore roast beef: beef, sharp American cheese, sweet and hot peppers and giardiniera mayonnaise on an onion roll, with jus on the side. The family-style entrees are Latin-style roast pork with rice and red beans, sausage ragu lasagna, fried chicken, and a braised beef lesso rifatto over grilled sourdough.
The owners run the butcher shop and the restaurant as one nose-to-tail operation, which lets them buy more from their farmers. Hill and Spangler both live in Kittery. Before the renovation began, customers helped unpack the furniture and carry it into storage. Hill told the Portsmouth Herald what she hopes the first snowstorm looks like there: a full room, a short menu because only two cooks can get in, and neighbors taking turns clearing each other's driveways before coming back to warm up and eat.
The two sides keep different hours. Tongue N Cheek serves dinner Wednesday through Saturday from 3 to 9 p.m. and Sunday from 3 to 8 p.m., and it is closed Monday and Tuesday, according to its website. Lunch is planned but has not started. Parties of six or more need a reservation. The Maine Meat counter is open Wednesday through Friday from 11 a.m. to 6 p.m., Saturday from 11 a.m. to 5 p.m., and Sunday from 11 a.m. to 3 p.m. On a Saturday that leaves a two-hour overlap, from 3 to 5, when you can stop at the counter for Sunday's roast and stay next door for dinner.
Wallingford Square, filled in by new owners
While Maine Meat was getting ready to move, Wallingford Square was gaining new places. Most of them came from one family. Deb McCluskey and her son, Michael, opened Salty Spirits, an oyster and cocktail bar, at 76 Wallingford Square on December 18, 2025, in the former Moodra salon, the Press Herald reported. In June 2026 the Portsmouth Herald covered their next opening, Dudley Street Pizza at 68 Wallingford Square. It draws on Deb McCluskey's start in her family's pizzeria in Winterport, Maine. Dudley Street takes pickup orders online.
Around the corner, Kittery Wine Bar opened at 10 Walker St. in the space that held the Kit & Co. children's clothing store until January, Mainebiz reported in July. It serves wine and small plates and also sells wine and gifts to take home. Check the wine bar's website for its current hours before you go.
Taken together, the Foreside has more choices for dinner and drinks this winter than last. Oysters and cocktails, a slice to carry home and a glass of wine are all within a few doors in Wallingford Square, and a few minutes away the Rogers and Whipple corner has a full dinner menu and a butcher counter under one roof.
The first weekend of December covers both ends
The holiday weekend that follows Thanksgiving week uses the same streets. On Friday, December 4, the First Congregational Church of Kittery Point holds its 110th Annual Christmas Fair from 3 to 7 p.m. at the 1729 Parish House, 23 Pepperrell Road. The fair has handmade gifts, baked goods, wreaths and food. Details are on the church's events calendar.
The Kittery Holiday Parade steps off from Traip Academy on Saturday, December 5, at 3 p.m. The route runs along Williams Avenue, Whipple Road and Wentworth Avenue, passes through Wallingford Square and climbs Government Street to John Paul Jones Park, where the tree lighting ends the afternoon, according to Kittery Rotary After Hours. Tongue N Cheek's regular Saturday dinner service starts at 3 p.m., the same hour the parade steps off.
On Sunday, December 6, the Kittery Community Market holds its annual Holiday Sip & Shop from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m., inside Blue Mermaid and Tributary Brewing Co. at 10 Shapleigh Road, with 25 local artisans. Maine Meat opens at 11 a.m. on Sundays, so a stop at the butcher counter fits easily after the market.
In 2024 Landgarten described the corner of Rogers and Whipple as a hub linking separate parts of downtown. On December 5 the parade route runs down Whipple Road and through Wallingford Square, where the Foreside's newest dining rooms sit.
At Legacy Properties Sotheby's International Realty, our agents follow how the Foreside is changing block by block, from a new butcher counter on Rogers Road to a new oyster bar in Wallingford Square. If you want to talk through what these changes mean for a home in Kittery, we would be glad to help. Work With Us.